Most moviegoers, even a lot of horror fans, were sick to death of "found footage" movies by 2012 or 2013. For those unfamiliar, found footage is a loose classification of movies that are intended not to feel like regular films but footage that real people could have shot. It's also grown to include the "mockumentary" format (i.e. Lake Mungo, Strange Harvest), where the footage is presented as part of a simulated documentary, and the "screenlife" format (i.e. Unfriended, Host), where the audience is seeing a computer screen being used by one or more characters.
Independent filmmakers experimented with this concept as far back as the late 1960s, but the foundational example is generally believed to be the second half of the infamous Cannibal Holocaust. Still, the subgenre didn't catch on until The Blair Witch Project became a surprise hit in 1999. About a decade later, Paranormal Activity cost $15,000 to produce and made $200 million worldwide. Studios realized just how profitable these movies could be and cranked them out nonstop for the next few years...and a lot of them were not great. The backlash was a contributing factor to a new wave of polished, thematically rich horror films that has been going strong for over a decade and shows no signs of slowing down.
So found footage has become something of a niche subgenre again, and it honestly works better this way. Very few of them get a theatrical release anymore, but the rise of streaming services has been instrumental in their continuing presence. Tubi has literally hundreds of them in its library, and recently another streaming site called Found.TV has emerged focusing only on these films. Both sites are free to use, you just have to put up with ads. They are still getting made constantly as its a style that's naturally low cost and thus extremely accessible to filmmakers hoping to make a name for themselves. In the last couple of years, I've noticed a trend in American found footage that I find super interesting - films made in a specific area and incorporating local culture and folklore into their stories. I haven't seen anyone else talking about this, so I'm proposing the name "regional found footage" for now. Here are some examples.
Frogman (2024)
This is the movie that made me want to write something like this. In the year 1999, the young Dallas accidentally captured a giant frog-like creature on his primitive video camera. His adult life has been difficult and Dallas has become obsessed with the idea that everything will get better if he can just prove “Frogman” exists, so he travels back to Loveland, Ohio along with two friends to find the cryptid.
What makes this so fun is that the “Loveland Frog” is a real local legend - a four foot tall frog creature that has been the target of alleged sightings since 1955. The movie incorporates a lot of genuine, amusing merchandise sold in the area, which makes the whole thing feel very grounded. Things get weird by necessity near the end and at first it seems like it has a typical found footage ending, but this is actually a fake out. The ending goes on a little longer and brings Dallas's character arc to its conclusion, a touch of creativity that I really appreciated. A sequel, Frogman Returns, has been playing at festivals this year, I'll see it the first chance I get.

Mothman (2022)
Let's move on to a much more famous American cryptid. The Mothman is a flying red-eyed creature that people have claimed to see in the vicinity of the West Virgina/Ohio border since the 1960s. Some stories even portray Mothman as some kind of harbinger of woe, his arrival foretelling the collapse of a bridge across the Ohio River in 1967.
Amanda has returned to the area with a camera for a filmed investigation of the disappearance of her younger brother Dakota, who vanished in the woods years earlier after becoming obsessed with Mothman. The acting is very rough and the first half is mostly interviews with friends and relatives, which is an unfortunate combination. Things do pick up in the second half when they find Dakota’s footage and the audience is treated to some impressively creepy sights. It was filmed mostly around Logan, Ohio but there is a scene across the river in Point Pleasant, West Virginia, a town with a real statue of Mothman.
#MissingCouple (2024)
A slow-paced movie that tried to replicate the famous marketing campaign of The Blair Witch Project in the era of social media. Austin and Janna (played, as is typical in these films, by Austin and Janna Jenkins) are social media stars who move into a secluded property in Centreville, Mississippi. Something sinister happened to them there, and a mysterious amateur detective is analyzing their footage while exploring the same property. The movie even foregoes end credits for the sake of its illusion, but 25 years after Blair Witch, very few viewers are going to be fooled by these tricks.
Most of the footage of the couple doing their thing is quite dull - it’s hard to imagine their content would get a large audience, but it does incorporate the unique history of Centreville in an interesting way. There's an urban legend that over a thousand black soldiers were murdered by racist white soldiers at Camp Van Dorn, something that historians haven't been able to substantiate but in this movie, it's a possible explanation for the shadowy figures lurking in the area.
Primal Darkness (2026)
A smart movie about the disappearance of Cole Harrington (played by Brown), a host of a popular internet show about hunting. Harrington ventures deep into the Nevada desert pursuing a mountain lion suspected of murdering nearby livestock, but there’s a different kind of predator lurking just out of view. Brown acquits himself well in the lead role - Cole feels like someone who could genuinely anchor a compelling show, which isn’t often true with this sort of premise.
This one doesn't necessarily focus on a specific local legend, but it uses a lot of details about the area in a way that gives the film its texture. There’s a section about halfway through where the focus suddenly shifts to two other characters discuss the archaeological history of the region. An interview with a local rancher gets into detail about the difficulty of raising livestock in the desert. It may not sound very exciting, but this sort of thing really grounds the story, at least before the horror sets in. The final scenes are filmed with an infrared night vision that emphasizes the color red rather than the typical green and it makes for some seriously potent scares.
Creature of the Pines (2026)
The huge Pine Barrens forest in the southern half of New Jersey has inspired spooky stories for centuries. It's the home of another classic American cryptid, the Jersey Devil, and a place where numerous hikers claimed to have heard a whispering voice. The latter is the focus of this well-made mockumentary that is more frightening than a lot of viewers will expect.
The fake documentary incorporates recovered footage from several different campers who went missing without a trace in the woods, all of them lured by soft whispering. It's not as convincing as something like Strange Harvest, but it does create a sense of scale, like this has been happening for ages. The big scares are also impeccably staged, making good use of space and suspense.
I suspect we'll see more of these in the coming years. Making use of local stories and places is a great strategy for low budget filmmaking. This subgenre encourages creativity and ingenuity like few others, which is part of the reason I'm so drawn to it. So maybe I'll continue this next year, or maybe I'll do something else. I'd love to do more Horror Around the World, but I only have about a dozen new countries and I need 31. For now, Happy Halloween!




No comments:
Post a Comment